Wednesday, November 18

Latin America Aims to Safeguard Minors on Social Media: What Are the Implications for Everyone’s Privacy?

Proposed Regulations on Social Media Access for Minors

In February 2025, a proposal reached the Mexican Senate aimed at preventing children under the age of 14 from accessing social media platforms. Additionally, it seeks to require parental consent for teenagers aged between 14 and 17 years. This initiative also includes mechanisms to verify users’ ages, posing a significant technological challenge: how can a platform ascertain whether a user is of sufficient age to utilise its services without collecting unnecessary personal information?

This issue is not isolated to Mexico but extends throughout Latin America, where various countries have begun deliberating restrictions on social media access for children and adolescents. Some proposals suggest verification methods involving official documents, while others explore technologies capable of estimating age based on facial features or digital behaviour.

This ongoing discussion is part of a study released by Derechos Digitales, which examines regulatory trends across 11 Latin American nations, warning that certain measures designed to protect young individuals might inadvertently alter internet access conditions for the entire population.

Evaluating Age Verification Strategies

The report, titled “Infancias y entornos digitales: tendencias regulatorias en América Latina,” authored by Marina Meira, reviews legislation and legislative projects identified from June 2024 to September 2026. Countries such as Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, and Uruguay have proposed age limits ranging from 13 to 16 years for accessing social media.

During the study period, none of the proposed prohibitions were enacted into law, even as these proposals progressed amidst insufficient evidence regarding their potential impacts, particularly in the context of Latin America.

To enforce these age restrictions, platforms need to establish whether a user meets the minimum age requirement. The study identifies two principal methods: verification, which utilises official documents or other reliable sources to confirm age, and estimation, which employs technologies that can approximate age based on physical characteristics or behavioural patterns.

However, both methods present challenges. Document-based verification may exclude individuals without acceptable identification or those unable to complete the process. Estimation systems, relying on facial analysis, also risk inaccuracies, with technical evaluations indicating that precision may fluctuate based on factors such as age, gender, geographical origin, and image quality.

Potential Privacy Implications of Age Verification

Behavioural estimation further complicates matters in Latin America, where economic disparities significantly affect access to electronic devices. When multiple individuals share a phone or account, these systems may conflate their activity patterns, leading to incorrect age assessments. This could result in adults being barred from certain services, or inadvertently activating protections meant for minors.

READ:  Meet the First AI Agent I Trust to Manage My Data Effectively

Moreover, the implications of these verification mechanisms extend beyond potential errors. To ascertain whether a user surpasses a specific age threshold, platforms might require information from adults, even if they are not subject to the restrictions themselves. Consequently, services that currently do not mandate age verification could begin to require such data to grant access.

Derechos Digitales emphasises that leaving online traces does not equate to the necessity for identification. While internet usage generates information that can be tracked, this differs from mandating users to verify their identities for platform access. The study cautions that age verification mechanisms could impose this requirement on services that currently do not demand it, raising significant concerns regarding user privacy.

In response to these challenges, some initiatives aim to mitigate risks. For instance, a project proposed in Argentina seeks to establish a state system capable of confirming whether an individual meets the required age limit without sharing sensitive data such as identification numbers or biometric images.

Addressing the Role of Technology Companies

Nevertheless, even this model raises questions about data management. Although a social media platform may only receive age confirmation, it remains critical to consider who conducts the verification, what information is retained, and whether records can be linked across different services to ascertain an individual’s digital activity.

The involvement of specialised companies tasked with age verification adds another layer of complexity. These providers may access data that, without appropriate protective measures, could be retained, merged with other records, or subsequently used for targeted advertising, commercial profiling, or surveillance.

Latin American proposals vary in their approaches to safeguarding against these risks. For example, a project presented in Peru this year mandates alternatives to official document verification and restricts the use and retention of collected data. Other initiatives reviewed do not clarify what information platforms may request, how it should be protected, or what will happen to it once age verification is conducted.

Consequently, Derechos Digitales advocates for a thorough evaluation of each measure’s necessity, the risks it aims to address, and whether less invasive alternatives exist.

Reforming Platform Algorithms and Practices

Age restrictions are among the most debated measures in Latin America, but the study identifies additional proposals aimed at fundamentally altering platform operations. These initiatives recognise that certain risks to children are also linked to the design of services and the business models that rely on them.

READ:  Mistral Unveils Le Chonk: An Open-Weight AI Model to Challenge OpenAI and China

Legislative attention has increasingly focused on algorithms that recommend content to keep users engaged for extended periods, persistent notifications, personalised advertising, and so-called “dark patterns”—design features that manipulate user decisions, potentially leading them to undertake unintended actions.

In Chile, for instance, a proposal seeks to impose responsibilities on platforms regarding the functioning of their algorithms. This project aims to prohibit designs that encourage addictive usage and patterns targeted at minors, while also limiting behaviour-based advertising and the use of personal data for profile creation.

Argentina has similarly examined measures to reform these practices, identifying factors like autoplay content, systems designed to prolong user engagement, and unrestricted interactions with strangers as risk factors.

Brazil has advanced with more comprehensive legislation. In September 2025, it enacted the ECA Digital, which imposes obligations on technological products and services aimed at, or likely to be used by, minors. This law mandates maximum privacy settings by default and imposes restrictions on the commercial use of minors’ personal data.

Challenges in Implementing Effective Regulations

Mexico has also explored changes in this area. In addition to the proposal for restricting social media access, the report highlights initiatives presented in 2025 and 2026 aimed at strengthening personal data protection, activating default privacy settings, and creating mechanisms for reporting harassment, sexual exploitation, and other forms of digital violence.

These proposals seek to ensure that technology companies bear greater responsibility for the services they provide, rather than leaving protection solely to families. However, the study warns that demanding excessive monitoring from platforms, user identification, or the removal of certain content may also jeopardise privacy, freedom of expression, and communication security.

Thus, Derechos Digitales argues that companies must be accountable for risks related to their products but under clear regulations that prevent unjustified expansions of surveillance or data collection. Regulatory frameworks should also incorporate independent oversight to monitor compliance with these obligations.

The Viability of Proposed Measures in Latin America

Latin American proposals have also drawn influence from laws enacted in other regions. The study highlights European models that impose obligations on technology companies and the Australian case, where a restriction prohibiting individuals under 16 from maintaining accounts on certain social media platforms came into effect in December 2025.

READ:  How Video Games Could Teach AI to Act: The Next Frontier in Artificial Intelligence

However, implementing similar measures in Latin America necessitates consideration of disparities in internet access and technological device availability. A study by the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), referenced by Derechos Digitales, indicates that home internet connectivity exceeds 90% in most of the six countries analysed: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Costa Rica, and Uruguay. Nonetheless, significant differences persist among socioeconomic groups, particularly concerning access to computers and other devices.

These inequalities present an additional challenge: the capacity of governments to enforce these regulations. The report notes that overseeing technology companies requires independent institutions, specialised personnel, and sufficient resources to scrutinise their practices and demand necessary changes. Without these conditions, platforms may ultimately dictate how to assess and address the risks associated with their services.

Concerns about the implications of these measures have already emerged in some legislative debates. In Ecuador, the National Assembly shelved a project on the responsible use of social media in June 2026, citing potential excessive restrictions on freedom of expression and access to information, issues surrounding personal data protection, and uncertainties regarding which authorities would oversee compliance with the law.

The research also highlights the importance of involving children and adolescents in decisions regarding the technologies they utilise. The internet serves as a space for learning, communication, information access, and social interaction. Therefore, protective measures must consider the risks they face alongside their rights and the varying contexts in which they engage with these services.

Furthermore, the report cautions that there remains a lack of regional evidence regarding the effectiveness of social media access prohibitions. Before adopting such measures, governments must assess whether they would genuinely mitigate risks and what potential consequences they could have for those using the platforms.

Derechos Digitales also emphasises the need for enhanced collaboration among countries. In this context, decisions that may seem technical—such as determining what data to request for age verification, who may retain it, and for how long—could lead to consequences that extend beyond youth access to social media. The challenge for Latin American countries will be to ensure that new regulations effectively reduce the risks faced by children without imposing restrictions that ultimately infringe upon the rights of all internet users.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *