Introduction of the Digital Fairness Act
On Friday, the European Commission unveiled the Digital Fairness Act, a legislative proposal aimed at ensuring consumers receive equal levels of protection both in the digital realm and when making purchases online or browsing websites. This initiative seeks to establish mechanisms to combat unfair trading practices, opaque pricing, targeted advertising based on sensitive data, and features that encourage impulsive buying.
The proposal is complemented by a revision of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation (CPC), which gives the European executive authority to investigate and impose fines of up to 6% of a company’s global annual turnover for non-compliance with the regulations.
Michael McGrath, the Commissioner for Democracy, Justice, the Rule of Law, and Consumer Protection, stated that these initiatives represent “the most ambitious reform of EU consumer protection laws in a generation.” He emphasised that to maintain market competitiveness, it is essential to safeguard buyers in all areas. “Shopping has never been more convenient, but that convenience must never come at the expense of fairness. [The Digital Fairness Act will] enable both consumers and businesses to fully leverage digital markets with confidence and security,” he stressed.
Key Provisions of the Digital Fairness Act
Despite these high expectations, advocates for digital rights raise concerns that the proposal lacks rigor, contains gaps, and does not include essential mechanisms to achieve its objectives.
The Digital Fairness Act outlines at least ten specific actions aimed at bolstering online consumer protection. Among these, it proposes prohibiting interfaces that facilitate manipulative commercial practices, such as displaying false alerts about limited product availability or employing messages that pressure users into making purchases.
Additionally, it will require online shops and services to clearly and understandably display product prices, even when transactions are conducted using virtual currencies within applications. For cultural and sporting events employing dynamic pricing, companies must inform users of the current price and the maximum possible cost while they wait in virtual queues.
Digital platforms will also need to provide users the option to disable design features that encourage compulsive usage and spending, particularly among minors.
In terms of digital advertising, the regulation proposes to restrict ads and pricing strategies aimed at children and adolescents, as well as those exploiting sensitive personal data. Influencers will be required to clearly identify commercial content they create and disseminate, while avoiding practices that could exploit the trust their audiences place in them.
Lastly, the initiative includes provisions to prevent automatic renewals of subscriptions, ensure customer service is provided by real people, simplify information regarding digital purchases, and establish guarantees for consumers using artificial intelligence agents to acquire products or services on their behalf. The European Commission estimates that implementing this set of measures could save consumers up to €13.7 billion annually.
Concerns About Potential Ineffectiveness
However, these promises have come under scrutiny from some digital rights advocates. Simona Levi, founder of Xnet, an institute for democratic digitisation, argues that the proposed safeguards against abusive practices are insufficient and may be designed to favour the interests of large tech companies.
“As always, our institutions are reluctant to upset the major powers that thrive on information manipulation, as they are the ones who flatter, care for, and maintain them,” the activist claimed.
Levi believes that the Digital Fairness Act does not comprehensively address the manipulation mechanisms used by platforms. For instance, she points out that instead of outright prohibiting addictive designs or requiring that related features be disabled by default, the proposal places the onus on users to activate protective measures.
The advocate also highlights that the draft neglects regulations concerning recommendation algorithms and limits transparency obligations to influencers, excluding media and public entities that also have the capacity to present advertisements as informational content. Furthermore, she notes that restrictions on using sensitive data for targeted advertising focus primarily on younger users, allowing companies to continue utilising basic information to segment advertising for the broader population.
Finally, the activist questions the inclusion of ambiguous concepts within the regulation that could facilitate the evasion of responsibilities and obligations set forth. “There is a clear influence from lobbyists. The listing is filled with adjectives like ‘falsely’ or ‘disproportionately’, which allow for debate over each case. More troubling still, only economic interests are protected: manipulation for attention or data extraction remains in a grey area,” she lamented.
It is important to note that the Digital Fairness Act is still a legislative proposal and is likely to undergo modifications during the relevant reviews. Levi concluded that addressing the inaccuracies and omissions identified in the initial draft will be crucial to ensuring that the initiative effectively meets its ambitious goals.
