Following allegations made by environmental activists, the Federal Attorney for Environmental Protection (Profepa) has announced it will hold SpaceX accountable for the pollution debris that has washed up at Playa Bagdad in Matamoros, Tamaulipas. This comes in the wake of an incident on 13 November when the booster of the Starship megacraft exploded during a flight test conducted by Elon Musk’s company from its Starbase facility in Texas.
Last week, members of the Conibio Global organisation staged at least two peaceful protests offshore to highlight the risks posed by the aerospace company’s operations to the ecosystems and communities in the Gulf of Mexico region.
Following the recent launch of the spacecraft, just a few kilometres from the US-Mexico border, the civil association reported that its technical team observed “thousands, possibly millions, of fragments of space debris” off the coast of Playa Bagdad. During their surveys, the activists identified white plastic remnants with grey tape, pieces of rubber tape, and items with blue glue, which are believed to correspond to the internal coating of the booster. These materials were found mixed with waste from tourism activities.
Additionally, they documented the deaths of a sea turtle and a dolphin in areas close to where the SpaceX booster explosion, known as Super Heavy, occurred. While there is a possibility that the deaths of these animals may be connected to the company’s activities, the environmentalists clarified that investigations into both cases remain ongoing to ascertain the causes and determine accountability.
Challenges in Cleanup Operations
Jesús Elías Ibarra Rodríguez, president of Conibio Global, cautioned that cleanup efforts have been complicated due to the region’s weather conditions and the size and quantity of the debris. Some of these pieces can weigh between 15 kilograms and half a tonne, making their removal significantly challenging.
In light of this situation, the collective has requested intervention from Claudia Sheinbaum and Mariana Boy, the head of Profepa, to address the issue and establish decisive mechanisms and measures to prevent SpaceX’s operations from further impacting Mexican coastlines.
In response, Profepa has confirmed that, in collaboration with the National Commission of Protected Natural Areas (Conanp), it is undertaking monitoring, response, and cleanup actions at Playa Bagdad following the arrival of debris potentially linked to the 13 November Starship launch.
The agency stated in a release that the waste began arriving on the Mexican coast around 7:30 am on 17 November. It clarified that “the collection is being managed by community monitoring brigades from Conanp, alongside the civil organisation Conibio, while Profepa is securing the materials and overseeing their transfer to the facilities of the Navy Ministry, where they will be safeguarded until the responsible company retrieves them for proper handling.”
Initial Findings and Environmental Impact
So far, around two kilograms of debris potentially related to the launch have been collected. Among the identified materials are rigid pieces of a whitish colour with cracks and jagged edges, as well as waste exhibiting light or yellowish hues and a rough, porous texture. However, the institution clarified that it has yet to be confirmed whether all the fragments originated from SpaceX’s operations.
Profepa noted that the spread of materials may have been facilitated by adverse weather and marine conditions observed between 13 and 17 November, including rising sea levels, elevated waves, and the presence of a northerly phenomenon. “These conditions encouraged the movement and dispersal of materials along the coastline. […] It is possible that not all collected waste is derived from the same event. Other fragments may remain on the seabed or dispersed offshore, potentially being transported later by currents and waves toward Playa Bagdad or other areas along the Tamaulipas coast,” the agency indicated.
The agency also emphasised that, as with previous launches, its personnel monitored the operation, and since the booster explosion was recorded, they have conducted surveys and oversight in collaboration with the Navy Ministry, Conanp, and other institutions to identify potential debris and address any environmental impact arising from the incident.
Concerns Over Government Response
Authorities have acknowledged the work of community monitoring brigades and urged the public to avoid touching, moving, or handling any materials found on the beach or in the sea, as identification and management should be left to specialised personnel. Any findings can be reported through dedicated channels.
Despite the announcement from Profepa, the environmental group contends that the Mexican government’s response to the situation has been insufficient. Since last year, the civil association has repeatedly expressed concerns regarding the detrimental impacts that Starship’s tests and failed flights have on various coastal regions of the country.
At that time, Profepa initiated a cleanup campaign in collaboration with the Navy Ministry, the National Commission of Protected Natural Areas, and environmental activists, focusing on an area deemed crucial for sea turtle nesting.
Claudia Sheinbaum, the President of Mexico, announced last year that her administration would prepare a lawsuit against SpaceX after determining that the company’s operations at the border posed risks both to safety and the ecosystems of Tamaulipas. However, the potential for legal action was ultimately dismissed, with the Mexican government opting instead to establish communication channels with the company and US authorities to receive notifications regarding launches from Starbase and jointly assess their possible environmental consequences.
In response, SpaceX denied that the remnants of Starship posed a danger to areas near its operational base and requested the support of Mexican authorities to recover the debris that fell in Tamaulipas, arguing that the wreckage belongs to them and that recovery efforts have been hindered by “unauthorised parts encroaching on private property.”
Meanwhile, Jesús Elías Ibarra Rodríguez, president of Conibio Global, asserts that the ongoing damage to ecosystems and communities in Mexico resulting from SpaceX’s operations in Texas persists for a simple reason: “Mexico is simply not defending itself.”
