Identification of an Anomaly in Speed Camera Operations
At the close of the previous year, it was brought to the attention of the House that an anomaly had been detected by National Highways, concerning the interaction between certain variable speed cameras and their associated signage on England’s strategic road network. This issue arose following the upgrade and installation of the camera system that commenced in 2019 during the tenure of the preceding government.
As a result of this anomaly, there were rare instances where drivers were not afforded adequate time to adjust to changes in speed limits or were erroneously recorded as speeding when the variable speed limit had been altered.
This malfunction was found to affect approximately 0.2% of the roadways in England, prompting immediate measures to prevent any wrongful enforcement and to rectify any historical enforcement actions that may have been erroneous. Individuals who could be identified and contacted have been offered compensation, and efforts will persist to provide redress to others as they are identified.
Collaborative Efforts to Resolve the Issue
Since the anomaly’s discovery, National Highways has been actively collaborating with the Home Office to conduct thorough technical and operational assessments of the relevant camera and enforcement systems. These investigations have revealed a potential additional complication regarding how these cameras may activate under certain conditions, stemming from the same upgrade initiated in 2019.
Modelling conducted by National Highways has indicated that the likelihood of encountering the specific operational conditions that could lead to this error is no more than 0.1%. Furthermore, there is no substantial evidence to suggest that this has adversely affected enforcement practices.
The government adheres to the highest standards of criminal proof and prioritises road safety. Ministers are resolute in their stance against any possibility that drivers could be incorrectly prosecuted or that enforcement integrity could be compromised.
Revocation of Type Approval and Contractual Actions
In response, the Home Office has opted to revoke the type approval status of the camera system, which permits the data collected from these cameras to be more readily accepted as evidence in certain legal contexts. The Home Office concluded that the identified issues with the camera could not be rectified within a satisfactory timeframe.
The camera system was acquired by National Highways under the assumption that it would retain its Home Office type approval. With this status now revoked, National Highways is terminating its contractual agreement with the device supplier, Verra Mobility, and is exploring all potential commercial and legal avenues that may be necessary.
Throughout this situation, enforcement has been maintained through various strategies, which will continue across all motorways and A roads. National Highways has ensured that compliance with legal standards remains at the expected high levels on these routes, ensuring their safety.
Enhanced Monitoring and Enforcement Measures
To further ensure compliance at relevant locations, National Highways is implementing additional traffic officer patrols to oversee these areas and is leveraging existing CCTV systems to aid in monitoring network compliance. This initiative complements existing safety measures, including stopped vehicle detection radars on all lane running sections and emergency areas, alongside the use of current ANPR cameras to identify offenders.
Variable speed signage will persist in being employed to enhance safety, manage traffic flow, and alleviate congestion.
It is important to emphasise that this matter impacts only a minimal number of cameras on a small fraction of the strategic road network. Drivers should not notice any changes in their road usage. Safety remains our paramount concern, and the further enforcement arrangements being introduced will ensure that any legal violations are addressed appropriately.
In summary, those who violate the law should anticipate enforcement actions.
Publication of the Westall Review Report
On this day, 17 November 2026, we are also releasing the Westall Review report, which investigates the origins of the initial technical anomaly and the subsequent management of the issue once it was identified. The review highlights crucial lessons for National Highways concerning corporate governance, crisis management, data and technology oversight, and stakeholder engagement.
The government acknowledges the report’s findings and accepts its recommendations. I would like to extend my gratitude to Tracy Westall for her diligence and commitment during this review process.
National Highways has embraced the review’s recommendations and has already commenced implementing necessary improvements, building on the steps that have already been taken.
My department will oversee National Highways’ progress in executing these recommendations and will hold it accountable through our established sponsorship frameworks.
