“`html
Good morning, and my sincere thanks to Chatham House for inviting me to deliver this keynote address for the third consecutive year. This event has evolved into a significant occasion in the CMA calendar, providing a valuable opportunity to reflect on our work and the motivations behind it.
In today’s fast-paced world, moments for pause and reflection are increasingly scarce. The pressures on our time and attention continue to mount, with fluctuating markets, evolving geopolitics, and rapid technological advancements contributing to a sense of urgency. In this climate of uncertainty, many individuals in the UK are feeling an acute sense of powerlessness.
The situation is multifaceted. While we possess agency, our lives are often shaped by the dynamics of economic power, which dictate:
- Who has the authority to make decisions and who can challenge them.
- Who can influence or disrupt markets.
- Who is subject to the decisions made by others.
These dynamics are present in every transaction, whether purchasing a product or service, contemplating a job change, or when a fledgling startup aims to compete with established firms. They also surface when a nation deliberates its future.
One of the CMA’s primary responsibilities is to assess where economic power resides, identify instances of excessive concentration, and explore how competition, consumer protection, and evolving market dynamics can contribute to a healthier economy. This is crucial because meaningful choices are integral to human dignity and essential for a sovereign nation.
Our concern extends beyond mere economic growth; it encompasses whether individuals, businesses, and communities possess genuine agency within that economy and whether its benefits are tangible across all areas. The CMA is committed to making these aspirations a reality.
Understanding Economic Power: Agency and Choice
The most fundamental manifestation of economic power lies in our individual ability to make authentic choices in our daily lives. This encompasses comprehending our choices based on transparent and precise information, coupled with the assurance of fair treatment. Absent these elements, feelings of frustration and anger naturally emerge, leaving individuals unable to exert meaningful control over their circumstances.
No one appreciates the sensation of being misled or manipulated by corporations. This underscores the vital importance of effective consumer protection, which serves as a counterbalance to disparities in information and power, thereby fortifying individual agency.
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act empowers the CMA to safeguard consumers from harm while providing genuine choices. Whether arranging your child’s first driving lesson, selecting a parking space, booking a holiday, purchasing a washing machine, or securing tickets for a concert, individuals should be able to do so with confidence—free from deceptive pressure tactics, misleading reviews, or hidden costs.
These everyday decisions significantly influence how individuals perceive their agency. When people can dictate their lifestyles and expenditure without manipulation or unfair practices, they experience enhanced control—a vital aspect of everyday economic freedom.
Those acquainted with the CMA’s initiatives will recognise that these scenarios are not arbitrary; they represent areas where we have already taken action under the new consumer regime, resulting in £2.3 million returned directly to consumers and fines nearing £12 million thus far this year.
However, it is essential to clarify that our implementation approach has not solely focused on penalising non-compliant firms. We also aim to empower businesses through clear guidance and constructive dialogue, even prior to the regime’s rollout. The majority of companies that uphold high standards should not be disadvantaged compared to those that blatantly disregard regulations. Consequently, we are leveraging our consumer protection powers to support compliant businesses in fulfilling their responsibilities to consumers.
The Impact of Agentic AI on Consumer Agency
One area I wish to emphasise within consumer protection is the transformative potential of agentic AI, which shifts from being mere decision-support tools to acting autonomously on our behalf. These technologies can help individuals navigate increasingly intricate markets, secure superior deals, and minimise effort, thus enhancing market functionality for millions. However, we are acutely aware of the associated risks.
Earlier this year, we released research analysing how agentic AI could redefine consumer agency. We discussed the critical importance of transparency, accountability, and control as individuals delegate more decision-making to these systems. While these technologies hold promise, the pivotal question remains whether they augment or diminish individual agency. The CMA is committed to fostering responsible innovation that safeguards individuals’ abilities to make meaningful choices in their lives.
We have also published guidance for businesses intending to implement agentic AI, clarifying that existing consumer protection laws remain applicable, and firms will be held accountable for the actions of the systems they deploy. Consumers must receive accurate information, have their rights respected, and companies cannot use technology as a shield to evade accountability.
As we stand eight months post-publication of these guidelines, we find ourselves at a pivotal moment, anticipating the initial wave of these services reaching UK consumers. We are actively engaging with the firms developing and deploying these technologies to ensure they comprehend their responsibilities. Concurrently, we are collaborating closely with other regulatory bodies, utilising the Digital Regulation Cooperation Forum to swiftly identify and address emerging risks. We are meticulously monitoring the rollout of agentic products in the UK and will not hesitate to act to safeguard consumer interests when necessary.
Powerlessness in Essential Services
The absence of agency in routine transactions can be frustrating; however, in the realm of essential goods and services, the ramifications of powerlessness can be even more profound. This reality was starkly illustrated when numerous predominantly rural households had their heating oil contracts cancelled following the outbreak of conflict in the Middle East earlier this year. Such instances highlight the critical need for effective consumer protection during vulnerable times, particularly when external forces exert influence over people’s lives.
This also reinforces findings from other areas of our work, indicating that geographical location can significantly affect the options and outcomes available in essential services. Thus, I wish to explore the second layer of power concerning essential services, where individuals frequently face limited meaningful alternatives in matters impacting their health, security, and living costs. The question of how best to provide these services remains a pressing issue for policymakers, evidenced by ongoing debates regarding the merits of public versus private control.
The CMA has extensive expertise in these markets, having conducted prior studies on funerals, children’s social care, and road fuel, as well as our ongoing investigations into private dentistry and childcare sectors. By analysing market operations, power distribution, and incentive structures, we are well-positioned to identify where unregulated market dynamics have failed to yield positive outcomes for individuals, businesses, and communities.
In the next three months, we will publish updates related to our road fuel, dentistry, and childcare initiatives, focusing on regional and local discrepancies in outcomes. To provide a brief preview:
- In road fuel, we will build upon our 2023 market study, concentrating on the factors contributing to persistent local price variations and how the newly launched Fuel Finder can stimulate more effective competition in the sector.
- In dentistry, we will utilise our unique information-gathering powers to conduct an in-depth examination that, for the first time, scrutinises the intricate interplay between public and private provisions in this essential service, shining a light on local and regional outcome variations.
The CMA’s market study capabilities enable us to pinpoint the causes of poor market outcomes. However, improving these outcomes often poses a greater challenge. In many instances, we recommend strategies to enhance competition or bolster consumer protection. Yet, for certain essential services, these interventions alone may be insufficient to recalibrate market dynamics and yield better results. Depending on the issues at hand, solutions may involve intensified competition, improved regulation, redesigned incentives, or, in some cases, increased public control.
Indeed, the CMA’s investigations in these areas can serve as a model for the government’s broader efforts to enhance market outcomes through its three taskforces focused on Public Control, Cost of Living, and Community Renewal. The CMA is actively contributing to government initiatives across all these fronts.
Challenging Established Power: Firms, Scale-ups, and Employees
Thus far, my focus has primarily been on the demand side of economic power. However, the capacity of firms, scale-ups, and workers to challenge existing structures is equally vital. An economy is inherently less dynamic when established businesses can entrench their dominance without checks, stifling opportunities for innovators, employees, and entrepreneurs. Such a scenario is detrimental to all stakeholders. Addressing this imbalance lies at the heart of the UK’s digital markets competition framework.
Consider contactless payments, which now account for approximately 60% of all card transactions in the UK. If you own an Apple device, you are likely utilising Apple’s digital wallet. Numerous businesses have expressed concerns that Apple’s fees and access regulations regarding near-field communication technology create significant hurdles for challengers attempting to innovate and compete. Last month, we announced proposals that would require Apple to eliminate specific barriers to entry, fostering an environment where exceptional UK businesses—especially within our renowned fintech sector—can develop new products and services, from payment applications to travel passes and digital keys.
This serves as one example of how we are leveraging the digital markets regime to combat substantial and entrenched market power. Another example relates to search services, where we are mandating Google to grant publishers meaningful control over how their content is utilised in its AI offerings, provide better insights into user engagement, and ensure clear attribution when that content appears in AI-generated responses. Such
