The graves of two soldiers, previously designated as ‘unknown’ from World War I, have been officially identified and rededicated, bringing closure to their families and honouring their sacrifices. The Ministry of Defence’s Joint Casualty and Compassionate Centre (JCCC), colloquially known as the ‘MOD War Detectives’, organised rededication services at the Commonwealth War Graves Commission (CWGC) Strand Military Cemetery in Belgium and the CWGC Grand-Seraucourt Cemetery in France this week.
Honouring Lieutenant Fred Naylor
Lieutenant Fred Naylor, born in 1892, dedicated himself to the war effort despite having a promising career in education. Commissioned as a temporary Second Lieutenant in July 1915, he served with the 8th (Reserve) Battalion of the Wiltshire Regiment until September of that year. His medal card indicates he arrived in France in late September 1916. By late October, he had been attached to the 4th Battalion The Buffs, where he was promoted to Lieutenant in July 1917, before returning to the Wiltshire Regiment later that same year.
In April 1918, Naylor found himself stationed in the trenches north of the River Lys. The day of April 10 began with intense bombardment, and by 3:30 am, enemy forces launched an attack that breached the battalion’s lines, isolating A Company. Although they fought valiantly for over an hour, they were eventually forced to withdraw to a more defensible position. The following days saw further heavy bombardment and fierce fighting around Ploegsteert Wood, resulting in significant casualties. Naylor was reported missing in action during this tumultuous period.
After the war, his remains were never recovered, leading to his name being inscribed on the Ploegsteert Memorial to the Missing. In July 1920, 74 casualties, including unknown officers from the Wiltshire Regiment, were buried at Strand Military Cemetery, having been moved from a German burial site. Recent evidence has suggested that one of these unknown officers was indeed Lieutenant Naylor.
Remembering Company Sergeant Major Herbert Richard Bannister
Company Sergeant Major Herbert Richard Bannister, born in 1889, enlisted alongside his two brothers, both of whom served in the Army Service Corps. Unfortunately, much of Bannister’s service record has been lost, leaving gaps in the understanding of his military journey.
According to the War Diary of his battalion, March 20, 1918, was relatively quiet. However, on March 21, the enemy launched a fierce attack at 4:10 am, prompting the battalion to prepare for combat. Despite their efforts, the 2/7th Battalion faced heavy losses, with many men later commemorated on the Pozieres Memorial following the war. Bannister was among those listed as missing, but a Red Cross inquiry revealed that his body had been recovered by German forces and buried near Hargicourt and Jeancourt.
In 2021, two individuals approached the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, proposing that an unknown sergeant major buried at Grand-Seraucourt Cemetery might be Bannister. Subsequent investigations by the CWGC, the National Army Museum, and the JCCC confirmed this identification.
A Lasting Tribute to Sacrifice
The rededication services were attended by serving soldiers from The Rifles and The Duke of Lancaster’s Regiment, highlighting the ongoing commitment to honouring the sacrifices of those who served. JCCC Caseworker Alexia Clark noted the significance of reuniting soldiers with their identities, expressing gratitude for the opportunity to work on the cases of Lieutenant Naylor and Company Sergeant Major Bannister. She emphasised the importance of ensuring that their sacrifices are remembered.
With new headstones crafted by the CWGC, both graves will receive perpetual care, solidifying their status as lasting tributes to the lives and sacrifices of these two soldiers. Polly Brewster, a Commemorations Case Officer at the CWGC, remarked on the honour of participating in the identification process, underscoring the poignant nature of the rededication services as a moment to reflect on the enduring human cost of war and the shared experiences of those who served.
